Showing posts with label misconduct. Show all posts
Showing posts with label misconduct. Show all posts

Friday, October 10, 2014

More on the Government Illegals Running the Immigration Courts


Attorneys are filing complaints against the sadistic clowns showing up for work in black robes at the Atlanta and Dallas immigration courts.  Will the Executive Office of Immigration Review do something, or will MaryBeth Keller and her cronies in the Office of General Counsel continue with their typically fake investigations and cover-ups?  

Analysis of misconduct complaint management from FOIA releases and lawsuit shows agency malfeasance.  To be serious about housecleaning, the agency needs to fire MaryBeth Keller, EOIR's leadership in the Office of General Counsel, and bring in the GAO for audit

A solo practitioner on Wednesday lodged with the Executive Office of Immigration Review (EOIR) a misconduct complaint against Atlanta immigration court case manager Dan Pelletier because he denied at the last moment her unopposed motion for a continuance to accommodate her maternity leave, and then yelled at her in a crowded court for showing up with her infant daughter, ultimately rescheduling the hearing per her initial request.

Attorney Stacy Ehrisman-Mickle's motion for a continuance is copiously cited and also accompanied by a detailed report from her physician.

 Ehrisman-Mickle's wrote to EOIR, in part:
 My complaint is simple: the IJ denied my motion for continuance for a master calendar hearing because he believed that being on maternity leave is not “good cause”. My initial consultation with the relevant clients (juvenile brothers) was on July 8, 2014. Due to financial constraints, the boys did not hire me right away. They went to their first master calendar hearing unrepresented on September 2, 2014. The boys and their mother came to my office on September 6 - the Saturday after their first master calendar hearing. The clients hired me that day and did not care that I had to file a motion for continuance due to my maternity leave. On Monday, September 8, I mailed a motion to continue their second master calendar hearing scheduled for October 7, 2014. The court received the motion on Tuesday, September 9. Counsel for DHS did not oppose my motion. The IJ did not rule on the motion until Thursday, October 2. I received the decision denying the continuance on Friday, October 3. I appeared with my clients this morning at their scheduled master calendar hearing. I was forced to bring my weeks old daughter with me as day care centers do not accept infants less than 6 weeks of age and I have no family in Georgia that could help me look after my baby. My husband is a truck driver and was out of state today. My family is in Iowa and my husband’s family is in New York and New Jersey. We have only lived in Georgia since November of last year. When the IJ saw me with my daughter, he was outraged. He scolded me for being inappropriate for bringing her. He questioned the fact that day care centers do not accept infants less than 6 weeks of age. He then questioned my mothering skills as he commented how my pediatrician must be appalled that I am exposing my daughter to so many germs in court. He humiliated me in open court.
Ehrisman-Mickle told me that that the EOIR supervisor of the Atlanta courts, Elisa Sukkar, called and expressed her frustration that Pelletier failed to record the exchange and indicated this meant Ehrisman-Mickle had the presumption of accuracy in any dispute about the facts, though Sukkar also indicated she might need further evidence from the attorneys then present.

Dallas Case Manager Dietrich Sims Targeted for Removal
On Thursday I received an email through a listserve from Attorney Niloufar Khonsari.  She indicated her own recent grievance filed against Dallas immigration court case manager Dietrich Sims, and called for other attorneys to share with EOIR their complaints at this time as well.

Khonsari is asking that EOIR terminate Sims and is asking attorneys to forward their complaints against Sims to ACIJ Dee Nadkarni at:  eoir.ijconduct@usdoj.gov

To make sure they don't ignore your Sims complaint, you can also send a copy to Khonsari.  Her email address is -- nilou AT pangealegal.org.

Khonsari Complaint
Khonsari was concerned because Sims first denied her motion for a change of venue because he found her client prima facie ineligible for relief even before his first master calendar hearing (he is eligible for cancellation and asylum). And then, when her client had flown from San Jose to Dallas (he'd been picked up for "driving too closely" and then brought by Dallas police into ICE custody before being released on bond) case manager Sims failed to call the pro bono attorney, per the telephonic hearing to which he had previously agreed.

Such burdens are unwelcome for most firms and a serious obstacle to due process when imposed on already overburdened nonprofits representing indigent clients. Khonsari's complaint to EOIR, including complaints from local attorneys preferring anonymity to incurring further wrath from Sims, states in part:
 -“[H]e is erratic and unpredictable.” 
 -“[He] never grants COV – especially not to CA.” 
 -“He made one of my clients travel from New York City for more than two years worth of hearings…” 
 -“[He] denies most cases.” 
 -“Sims acts as a prosecutor, rather than judge, and invented requirements, such as proving a prima facie case for asylum as a prerequisite to changing venue, that exist in no statute, regulation, or case law.” 
 -“Please file a complaint with the chief immigration judge [against Judge Sims]!” 
- One attorney recently reported that IJ Sims denied a child-client a continuance and ordered a deportation after the child had been granted special immigrant juvenile status. In that case, IJ Sims claimed he had no jurisdiction over the child's adjustment application and sua sponte, ordered the child deported.
Misconduct Investigation Data
The feeling among attorneys is that EOIR's system of  misconduct investigations is a farce. And a preliminary analysis of data released so far backs them up.

Since late 2013, EOIR has been releasing immigration judge misconduct complaints and investigations in summary form, and, since April, 2014 many of the associated underlying complaints and findings.

There are several huge problems with the release to AILA, represented in their FOIA litigation by Public Citizen.  But even the release as doctored by EOIR reveals some interesting results.

Here are some observations based on a quick analysis of the first "200" of their release (really 197-- three inexplicably are missing) from a spreadsheet, produced by Northwestern undergraduates Sam Niiro and Adelina Pak and a crosstab spreadsheet produced by Sam Niiro by complaint source and ACIJ, for the outcomes.

Summarized below are some glaring problems that stuck out as my colleague Professor Heather Schoenfeld and I began assembling data for a more systematic analyses of the release, and press for more accurate reports.

-The number of days lapsed between the conduct and the case being closed are incompatible with any process of remediation. 
Highlights include a complaint submitted by an attorney requesting the ACIJ's assistance with a request for an IJ's recusal that ACIJ Sarah Burr dismissed for "failure to state a claim" after a mere 2,793 days.   This is an outlier but the median range of several hundred days is not much more comforting. Nor are the problems with Gary Smith's "investigations," leaving aside for now his coverup of my own misconduct complaint. For instance, the Board of Immigration Appeals sent Smith a complaint noting an "IJs written order denying R[espondent]'s motion to reopen accuses counsel of attempting fraud," and the next day Smith "dismissed" the complaint "because it cannot be substantiated."  (Emphasis added.)

Nor is it encouraging to note rare punitive decisions taken after the offending IJ has been deporting thousands more, as when, responsive to allegations an IJ "maligned and exhibited hostility towards complainant's law firm, its attorneys, and clients" and intervened in "civil state court adoption proceeding involving an alien child and parent." ACIJ Larry Dean suspended an IJ on October 15, 2012, 1,026 days after the complaint was received.

Dean likewise ignored a complaint that an "IJ prematurely ended the proceedings following a terse exchange and did not adequately evaluate the removal charge," a complaint brought by the BIA on June 9, 2009 for behavior on July 18, 2007 and closed on September 8, 2010 with the IJs retirement.

-Lame or no responses predominate
"Oral counseling" leads all categories of responses (73), and an additional 64 are dismissed because they are "unsubstantiated" (28, including the one above), "merits-related" (22), failure to state a claim (8), disproven (4), or frivolous (2).
15 cases close because the IJ retires.  These are not 15 separate IJs but include multiple complaints against the same IJ--the exact number is not clear because of EOIR coding mistakes, about which EOIR refuses to comment).

-Single IJ terminated over AILA Objections  (#126)
I was contacted by an active AILA attorney in 2010 who felt EOIR was using the complaint as a pretext to go after the IJ for her rulings.  Keller, who managed the investigations, assigned Smith to do the dirty work, even though this was not among the courts he supervised.  The IJ EOIR fired had the reputation of being more progressive.  (She was dismissed after "IJ alleged to have misused position and equipment to influence court action against her husband" and related charges based on assisting her husband with his own traffic case.)

This is all of course the tip of the black ice floe that is EOIR.  Ehrisman-Mickle and Khonsari are to be commended for standing up to these bullies and on behalf of  integrity of a system that is sorely lacking in it.

(The disturbing scope and character of the misconduct complaint misrepresentations in the data released under the supervision of MaryBeth Keller will be discussed at another date, and also the actions of her colleagues in the agency's Office of General Counsel.)



Monday, May 20, 2013

New FOIA Lawsuits



from TVtropes.org







"from Matter of C.B.

I decided it was time to push back against the slow poke or nonresponsive replies to my requests for information under the Freedom of Information Act.  Sam Niiro and I are now filing pro se lawsuits.  Sam is just finishing his first year as a Northwestern undergraduate.  And many thanks to attorney R. Andrew Free who is taking over after we file them!

Complaint Against the Executive Office of Immigration Review
The first complaint, filed in April, was to obtain the case docket for "Matter of C.B." an August 15, 2012 Board of Immigration decision that, pathetically, had to be written in order to tell a Department of Justice attorney that respondents really do have a right to an attorney.   I requested the hearing history because I wanted to know how long it took someone locked up to have this due process right affirmed.  The coercion of detention pressures so many people to abandon their legal claims to residence and I wanted to document what this wait looks like.  

I had received precisely this information in response to a previous FOIA request, with the respondents' names redacted. But this time around the geniuses at the DOJ said they did not maintain this information.  (The problem is not terminology because I used the exact same language on both requests, as my complaint points out.)

Finally, please note in this decision and all BIA decisions the gross flaunting of the rule of law the EOIR perpetuates when it hides the names of the immigration judges, another symptom of the kangaroo court mentality among the folks who run that agency.  In exchange for the great power judges have they must submit their decisions to public scrutiny.  But of course kangaroo courts can provide this discretion and cloak these DOJ attorneys in the hangman's garb of anonymity.

Complaint Against the Department of Homeland Security, Office of Inspector General
The second complaint, filed a couple weeks ago, is on behalf of a woman who in 2011 was falsely imprisoned, kidnapped, and robbed by DHS employees when she was returning from Nigeria.  The Office of the Inspector General conducted an investigation that resulted in her being returned to the United States at government expense but the OIG is not releasing the underlying investigation results that led to this decision.   I'll be posting more details on her situation shortly.

EOIR, MaryBeth Keller email
Next up is the email to and from EOIR attorney MaryBeth Keller about the coverup that she participated in pertaining to the investigation of my own misconduct complaint against William Cassidy, the Atlanta immigration court attorney who deported U.S. citizen Mark Lyttle and then illegally failed to allow us to observe hearings, ordered me removed from the building, and then lied about it.

Ironically, Keller, point person for misconduct investigations, herself failed to comply with the FOIA law for over a year.  The EOIR is not among the components that consider employee FOIA responses in their performance reviews, something that needs to change.  Keller is the EOIR official who sucks up the misconduct complaints against the immigration judges and then, in violation of the statutes, helps her  colleagues sweep them under the rug.  There are statutes that require her to forward these complaints to the DOJ Office of Professional Responsibility or Office of Inspector General but last time I checked she and the rest of her colleagues were regularly violating these statutes.


Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Federal Judge Green-lights Lawsuit Against DOJ and DHS: William Cassidy's Actions to Receive Strict Scrutiny







At the instigation of immigration judge William Cassidy, a former deportation agency prosecutor, on April 19, 2010 various federal officials and Paragon Systems, Inc. guards interfered with my Constitutional rights to observe deportation hearings for the detained docket in Atlanta, Georgia.  Last week, Atlanta-based Eleventh Circuit District Court Judge Orinda Evans filed an order denying the federal government's motions to dismiss my pro se lawsuit based on those events and related ones.

For background on the underlying complaint, please go here.



The order allows me to show a jury the violations of my First and Fifth Amendment rights by guards employed by Paragon Systems, Inc. , and also to seek injunctive relief against William Cassidy, aka, the immigration-judge-who-deported-a-North-Carolina-born-U.S.citizen-who-speaks-no-Spanish-and-has-no-relatives-in-Mexico-to-Reynosa.  Judge Evans also denied his accomplices' motions to dismiss my lawsuit, and so they also remain as named federal defendants who may be ordered to follow the law that they are charged with enforcing.

These federal defendants are:  Eric Holder, Attorney General; Juan Osuna, Director, EOIR; Fran Mooney, Assistant Director for the Office of Management Programs, EOIR; MaryBeth Keller, Assistant Chief Immigration Judge, EOIR; Gary Smith, Assistant Chief Immigration Judge, EOIR; William Anthony Cassidy, Immigration Judge (EOIR); Cynthia Long, Atlanta Court Administrator, EOIR; Darren Eugene Summers, DHS.



Part of the order, alas, grants Department of Justice attorney/adjudicator William Cassidy absolute judicial immunity, from the damages portion of the lawsuit.  I will be appealing that portion of the order on the grounds that Congress deliberately denied immigration judges any authority to control the physical movement of anyone in their hearings or anywhere else, unlike federal judges who do have legal authority over the physical movement of spectators in their court rooms.  Congress provides federal judges the prerogative to issue orders to law enforcement personnel to make arrests and control the physical movement of people in their court rooms, and provides other contempt authority as well.  None of these are in the statute circumscribing the contempt authority for immigration judges, which at most would be to issue civil fines, but only if authorized by the Attorney General, and the A.G. has not provided even this limited authority.  Therefore, precedents that protect court room abuses by Article 3 federal judges do not apply to immigration judges.

(My complaint is that Cassidy unlawfully closed hearings and the damages are claimed because in addition to this, he ordered guards to remove me from the building.)

In addition to Cassidy lacking contempt authority, save the robes and other paraphernalia, immigration hearings are closer to kangaroo courts than actual judicial venues, including other administrative law proceedings.  Unless the courts want to rule that federal employees who wear black gowns can escape accountability for their civil rights violations, juries should have the opportunity to hold accountable immigration judges, along with the rest of the thugs in that gang.  

Thursday, January 17, 2013

Massachusetts Native, Deported for Ten Years, Sues for $12 Million




The tag for the Lawrence General Hospital infant crib Robert's mother saved from when he was born there; it has the same date and other information that appears on his official birth certificate.



Robert's Amended Complaint, filed October 4, 2012 by the law office of Gerald Phelps, Halifax, MA

Robert Dominguez was born in November, 1979 in the Lawrence General Hospital, a modest brick building in the heart of Lawrence Massachusetts, about a 30 minute drive north of Boston.  According to the first line of the 14th Amendment, that would make him a citizen of the United States: "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside." 


But in 1998, deportation agents interviewed Robert, then 18 years old, at the Middleton jail.   They asked him for proof of his claim to U.S. citizenship, "I'm American, I don't need to claim U.S. citizenship.   If I'm born here, why do I need to claim it.  I'm a U.S. citizen, I'm born here, that's all that matters.  I let him know my part."

Robert went back to his cell and thought that was the end of the matter. But when he was released, instead of being picked up by the bus that was supposed to shuttle him to the Lawrence Court House, he was picked up by some guys in green uniforms.  "They kidnapped me from Middleton and brought me to New Hampshire, and kept kidnapping me to different systems." Over the course of a couple months, deportation agents ignored his statements about being born in the United States and shuffled him around a few deportation jails in New Hampshire and Massachusetts before taking him to a detention center in Batavia, New York where, he said, "A lot of people were on a hunger strike.  'If you bring me back to my country they're going to kill me.'  I'm thinking, What the hell is this place?" 

 For the first time he was given a copy of some bogus paperwork his parents put together in the 1980s and that Robert didn't know about.  Those documents stated, incorrectly, that Robert was born in the Dominican Republic. Robert also has two social security numbers, one from shortly after he was born, and another from  after he returned from the DR with his mother.

Robert didn't have an attorney, nor did he have in his possession his certified birth certificate with the same information on the Lawrence hospital bed tag above.  And like every single individual on the planet, he lacked first-hand knowledge of where he was born.  (An immigration judge once told me that the testimony from respondents about their place of birth is always heresy and should not be credited: the only relevant testimony on this question would be that of a respondent's mother, who is pretty much never present for these proceedings.) 

Knowing nothing about documents that Robert himself did not create, had never seen before, could not authenticate, and containing information he could not verify, he conceded alienage and asked the Department of Justice attorney John Reid, an immigration judge, not to deport him because even though he was learning he'd been born in the DR, he'd believed all his life he was a U.S. citizen.  The hearing recording reveals Robert telling Reid,
I never have had an immigration problem, getting jobs, being part of a school. It never affected me. They always asked me for my papers and where I was born and I would always tell them I was born here in the United States because that's what I thought all my life, until recently I just found out I was born over there, and I never had any problems with none of that. And if you could really reconsider me not getting deported, I would really appreciate it.
Robert explained, "I got all these very professional American government people right there telling me [I'm not a U.S. citizen] and I'm like, 'Wow...'"  Reid, who is still deporting folks from the same court in Batavia, never asked for more information about why Robert thought he was born in the United States.  Speaking over a televideo contraption set up in the Batavia, New York detention center--the only attorney in the room with him being the guy working for the government and trying to deport him, Robert begged Reid for mercy, when what he should have been demanding is the enforcement of his Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment due process rights, including a right to an attorney and not what Reid mentioned, a gimmicky list of folks who supposedly would provide pro bono legal services. 

The U.S. Constitution requires neither that Robert nor anyone else do something impossible, i.e., recall first-hand the details of her birth, nor that one have legal expertise on the nuances of deportation and citizenship laws.  And yet that is exactly what the government is demanding when it deports people, including U.S. citizens, without providing assigned attorneys.  

(In many regions, the deportation officers, the IJs, and especially the respondents, know that referencing these provider lists is a pro forma judicial joke at the expense of the respondents and the larger public appalled at what the government is doing in the name of "the people."  Some regions have lists that have top-notch nonprofit attorneys who do excellent work but in too many places these lists are distributed only so the agency appears to comply with a regulation requiring the EOIR to maintain such a list.  Even if there really is a working number and a real attorney answers, they are not able to provide individual assistance without compensation to every confused kid with a rap sheet who calls them, and indeed that was exactly what Robert said happened, and what he said was common knowledge among the other folks locked up with him.   Nonprofits firms and pro bono attorneys are doing great work, just as did individual attorneys before the landmark Gideon case; indeed it is precisely the benefits that some receive as a result of this work that makes clear the importance of a right to assigned counsel for everyone.  Robert is not alone; many of the U.S. citizens who are being deported have this happen for very similar reasons: parents creating confusing paper trails that assist perhaps education abroad or their own immigration status, documents that have implications for their children of which the children are entirely unaware.)

The next thing Robert knew is that Reid ordered him deported to the Dominican Republic, and not to return for at least ten years.  His file shows a round-trip trip ticket booked on American Airlines from Buffalo, New York to Santo Domingo, leaving on October 13, 1999 and returning on October 14, 1999.  Robert, of course, only used half of that ticket.  When he finally overcame his fear of being imprisoned for trying to return before ten years, he put together the documents his mother had saved from when he was born in Lawrence, presented them to the U.S. consulate in Santo Domingo, and in 2009 was issued a U.S. passport and used that to purchase with his own funds a ticket home.  That passport has since been revoked and is part of Robert's damages in the pending lawsuit. 

The next post will describe Robert's time in the DR, including some amazing stories about his work as a telemarketer for global finance firms, including accounts of fraud by AIG and other companies.  


Thursday, December 6, 2012

ICE Agents Deported Chicago Residents Without Criminal Histories Based on Unsubstantiated Claims of Gang Membership



Federal agents deployed through a special "Gang Surge Operation" have been arresting and deporting people based solely on unreviewed allegations of alienage and gang membership, including juveniles.  Moreover, according to the Chicago data, none of the program's key objectives are being met, an outcome ignored by the agent who reviewed this and indicated satisfaction that U.S. residents merely accused of gang membership and minor crimes were being deported with neither criminal nor immigration hearings.

In 2011 the Department of Homeland Security's (DHS)  Office of Inspector General (OIG) issued a report evaluating how effectively Immigration and Customs Enforcement's (ICE) Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) was identifying so-called criminal aliens and ensuring their deportation.  The report was focused on identifying false negatives, that is, whether immigrants with criminal records were not being flagged for deportation.  In reviewing agency actions, the OIG described a program that appeared to be deporting people who had no actual criminal record, if they were "alleged gang members."

Concerned about the due process violations this might occasion, I submitted a request under the Freedom of Information Act for the OIG to release to me the files of the Gang Surge Operation they reviewed.  They did not release these but they did release some spreadsheets and analysis.



The FOIA response I received reveals that ICE was plucking people off the streets of Chicago who had no criminal history, asserting they were breaking laws that should land them in state courts and jails, and then, instead of turning them over to state or local authorities, throwing them out of the country using Stipulated Removal Orders.  Also, most of the alleged violations were inconsistent with the high falutin' mission of attacking dangerous transnational cartels trafficking drugs and weapons, but were for relatively benign events, like "defacing private property," (graffiti) or possessing small amounts of marijuana.

Here is the first part of the record from the screen shot above, the first two columns blacked out are the person's first and last names.  The column with the word "none" is for the codes of previous arrests from the NCIC database.


That is, instead of the police arresting people and then, after they have been convicted and served their sentences, turning them over to ICE, ICE was arresting people, including juveniles, and then deporting them based purely on allegations of crimes and gang membership and without any administrative or judicial review.

Moreover, although a main concern of the OIG research was to learn whether people being released on their own recognizance were committing crimes and not showing up for their hearings, 25 of the 27 who were deported through STIPs had no prior orders of removal.  This was their first time in ICE custody.  The agent reviewing this data:  1) describes a policy to deport alleged gang members who have never been convicted of a crime; ("..discussed that unless there is a conviction, subjects are often released," in other words, discussed the presumption of innocence and how Gang Surge Operation could supersede this;  2) grossly mischaracterizes the program success by collapsing the number of individuals whose records required mandatory detention with those who signed Stipulated Removal orders, thus misleadingly suggesting ICE was deporting recidivist gang members, and overlooking the extent to which ICE was deporting non-criminals without hearings; 3) recommends OIG should no longer review whether those arrested through Gang Surge Operation have records consistent with mandatory detention.  

The analyst writes: "I found that 33 case files indicated that the individual was subject to mandatory detention and 14 files indicated that the custody decision was discretionary."  But then later the analyst states, correctly, "Of these files, 33 were instances where detention was mandatory due to criminal history or that the individual had signed a stipulated removal..." (emphasis added). The more accurate breakdown is that only 7 of the individuals required mandatory detention and 40 did not, among whom 25 nonetheless signed stipulated orders of removal and were deported and another signed a stipulated order of removal and then an immigration judge released him or her.
ICE’s Office of Investigations arrested 1,785 gang members and associates, criminals, and other aliens during its 2009 Gang Surge Operation. The operation was part of the larger, nationwide Operation Community Shield, which targeted transnational street gangs involved in human smuggling and trafficking, narcotics smuggling and distribution, weapons smuggling and arms trafficking, and other crimes. According to ICE’s Office of Investigations, violent transnational criminal street gangs represent a threat to public safety in neighborhoods across the United States. ICE’s Office of Investigations generally recommends that ERO detain gang members to protect the public.
We reviewed 52 gang member arrests during the Gang Surge Operation in 2009. Upon arrest, ICE turned the alien gang members over to ERO custody for removal. For each case, we determined whether ERO overturned ICE’s initial custody recommendations and released the aliens. Of the 52 arrests, 47 (90%) aliens were subject to mandatory detention or ICE detained them because they posed a danger to the public. ICE’s Office of Investigations recommended that ERO release three (6%) aliens because they were juveniles (two) or participating in an ongoing ICE investigation (one). The remaining two (4%) aliens were incarcerated in federalprisons or local jails. We did not identify cases where ERO overturned ICE’s initial custody recommendations. However, we determined that immigration judges later released six of the aliens from detention, and ERO released one into an ATD program.
If you know a little bit about how ICE agents really work, i.e., their own self-acknowledged "ruse operations" in which they impersonate everyone from insurance agents to Mormon missionaries, how they stake out church parking lots where Latinos go and write down license plate numbers, or hire local off-duty sheriffs to use their local law enforcement vehicles to pull people over for pretextual traffic stops and then hand them over to ICE, then this sounds lots of alarms.

The language of a "threat to the community" based on alleged gang membership alone and not criminal convictions is a huge red flag for potential ICE abuses.  (The doctrine of pre-emption is not just a problem in international law.)  I wondered, who exactly are these people ICE is arresting under its Gang Surge Operation and how can they be deported if they don't have any criminal records? And then I filed a FOIA request.

In late October I received a reply.  By coincidence the sample of the nationwide program OIG studied was based on the program in Chicago.  Here's what I learned:

FROM FOIA/PA No 2012-180:
-Among the 52 Chicago residents arrested through the Gang Surge Operation,  27 were deported on the basis of Stipulated Removal Orders (STIPs) -- meaning they signed a document in which they relinquished the right to an immigration hearing -- but only seven had been convicted of any crime, and none of the 27 were charged with the alleged violations supposedly triggering their ICE arrests.  

-Many of the individuals deported through the STIPs have traffic stops or other minor violations associated with their ICE arrests.  No legal status is provided, so it is unclear how many were legal residents, overstayed visas, or had entered without inspection.

In Gang Surge, ICE could, and apparently did, pick up people, including kids, told them to sign something, and shipped them out of the country, even if they had broken no laws.   (One entry says the individual has no criminal history and gives no reason at all for the arrest but lists the individual as a "Latin King.")  In two cases ICE released juveniles after their arrests--there is no information on how long they were held--but an additional two on the list of those who signed STIPS were arrested by ICE supposedly because of "possession of alcohol by a minor" and "possession of liquor by a minor."  One subsequently was "bonded out by an IJ" but the other was deported.

Again, the OIG evaluation focused on whether ICE was releasing criminals, and had no comment at all on these cases of juveniles signing stipulated removal orders.  Also, though one may be a minor and not a juvenile under state law for possession of alcohol, the definition of a juvenile in federal law, which governs deportation proceedings, is anyone under 21.
What is the definition of a federal juvenile delinquent? (top)
A juvenile is a person who has committed an act of delinquency, but has not attained his/her 21st birthday and is sentenced under the Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act (JJDPA) (18 U.S.C. 5031 through 5042). In corrections, the term juvenile, juvenile offender, juvenile resident, student, and resident are used interchangeably and are considered synonymous. For more information, visit http://www.ojjdp.gov  (from the Federal Bureau of Prisons)
Most of this information I requested was not released to me and the material I received was highly redacted. I will be filing an appeal and will perhaps learn more about how this program was and is being run.


Thursday, May 3, 2012

Immigration Court Agency, Homeland Security, and Private Guards Sued for Civil Rights Violations



On April 19, 2010 guards followed an unlawful order to remove me from the Atlanta federal building housing the immigration courts.  Documents obtained under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) show that in the months following this, supervising employees of the Executive Office of Immigration Review (EOIR) and the Federal Protective Services (FPS) tried to cover up these events, in particular, to disguise the fact that the order to remove me while I was engaged in court observations for findings reported in The Nation magazine and scholarly publications came from the immigration judge William Cassidy, the same individual reported for the first time on this blog as having deported U.S. citizen Mark Lyttle.

On April 18, 2012, I filed a complaint in the United States District Court in the Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division charging violations of the First, Fourth, and Fifth Amendments to the United States Constitution (Bivens v. Six Unknown Named Agents of the Federal Bureau of Narcotics), and False Imprisonment, Assault, and Battery.

Summons were executed and immediately sent to the appropriate agencies for service on Defendants Eric Holder, Attorney General; Juan Osuna, Director, EOIR; Fran Mooney, Assistant Director for the Office of Management Programs, EOIR; MaryBeth Keller, Assistant Chief Immigration Judge, EOIR; Gary Smith, Assistant Chief Immigration Judge, EOIR; William Anthony Cassidy, Immigration Judge (EOIR); Cynthia Long, Atlanta Court Administrator, EOIR; Darren Eugene Summers, FPS; Inspector DOE, FPS; Paragon System, Inc. Guard DOES 1-4; and Paragon Systems, Inc.

The complaint relies on a contemporaneous transcript of a Paragon Security Systems, Inc. guard's call to the FPS Battle Creek Michigan MegaCenter, obtained pursuant to a FOIA request.  That call, and 423 pages of e-mail to and from EOIR public affairs attorney Lauren Alder Reid, shows that the EOIR was closely monitoring my movements among immigration courts nationwide and had convened to discuss "banning" me from hearings following my reporting for articles in The Nation magazine that resulted in a 2011 Project Censored awards for number four out of  the Top 25 Censored Stories in 2010.

In addition to detailing unlawful closures of hearings and cover-ups of this on two occasions by William Cassidy, Cynthia Long, MaryBeth Keller and Gary Smith, all EOIR employees, the complaint details numerous violations of judicial procedures for the purpose of highlighting the unlawful practices that the DOJ was attempting to hide.

According to the complaint:
125.  On April 13, 2010, a desk clerk working at the immigration hearing rooms in the CCA facility at Lumpkin, Georgia sent the following message to court administrator Ray Bethune:
"Subject: Problem...
Ray- That reporter woman is back and being argumentative about being allowed in the Courtroom.  The courtroom is full! 97 detainees.  We are suggesting that she wait until we do that mass removal and then allow her in.  She refuses to take no for an answer.  She is arguing with Sgt Perry also.  Any suggestions on how to handle this?" (EOIR FOIA 2010-12055, p. 315, received January 9, 2012 in response to Plaintiff request of June 3, 2010)
    126.  "Mass removals" are not lawful under EOIR or any other DOJ procedures.  According to the Immigration Judge (hereafter IJ) Benchbook: "[A]ll salient points discussed in the non-detainee setting must be covered in the detainee setting as well. In the detainee setting, it is important to get individualized answers from each respondent to important matters."
    127.  The windowless room in which the 97 people may or may not have heard their names called, and may or may not have heard and understood they were all being ordered removed, at all times relevant to this complaint  had a seating capacity for approximately 24 people. 
    128.  Plaintiff has been physically present in that room.  Based on information and belief, the immigration judge running that hearing was J. Dan Pelletier.  Based on information and belief, it would be impossible for Pelletier, reciting his script from a dais in an Atlanta court room and observing the Lumpkin hearing room via televideo, to have visually discerned individual respondents, much less engage each of them in any meaningful exchange. 
    129.   Mass hearings of any sort are not consistent with judicial procedures.
 The complaint states that the same absence of judicial conduct that harms respondents means that immigration judges may not claim the sovereign immunity from lawsuits available government officials who engage in truly judicial conduct.

Thursday, February 9, 2012

FOIA Responses Reveal More Misdeeds by Atlanta's William Cassidy, DHS Employee-of-the-Decade



Excerpt from April 19, 2010 transcript of Atlanta security guard telling Megacenter operator in Michigan that immigration court adjudicator William Cassidy told the guards to remove me from the immigration court waiting area minutes earlier. This was illegal and the EOIR and DHS conspired to cover this up, as additional documents also obtained through FOIA requests demonstrate below.

The fact pattern in my own case is one being endured now by Edward Bloodworth and his wife. This post describes Cassidy's current law-breaking and then shows how it is of a piece with his past misconduct


NEW: SUBSCRIBE FOR UPDATES!


Yesterday afternoon I had an upsetting conversation with Edward Bloodworth, a landscaper in Macon, Georgia whose wife has Stage 3 breast cancer and is locked up because of William Cassidy, the guy who in 2008 deported a U.S. citizen and regularly removes observers and even spouses from his court, in violation of a regulation requiring otherwise.

The short version of Edward's narrative is that on April 27, 2011 Cassidy told Edward that his wife of ten years, who was in the Gwinett County Detention Center with an "immigration hold" was not in Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) custody and that is why she was not in court at the time indicated on her Notice to Appear (NTA).

Cassidy then said he was closing the case, meaning he was not going to authorize ICE to pursue its deportation order per the NTA ICE issued Edward's wife in the fall of 2010 after she was arrested for shoplifting. Cassidy also said that if she were in ICE custody, then they would be releasing her on bond.

Instead of releasing Edward's wife, however, ICE moved her to the Irwin County Detention Center three hours south of Atlanta and a week later issued a new NTA containing the same grounds as the initial one -- a visa overstay--even though she and her husband married in 2000 and, according to Edward, had the bona fides of his I-130 marriage petition approved in 2005, though receipt of the actual green card still is pending. In other words, she should not be detained.

No record of her appeared on the ICE locator system last year when Edward desperately searched for her after she had vanished from Gwinnett--it took a week before she could call him--and none exists today.

Meanwhile, Edward's wife cannot even obtain a bond hearing, and Cassidy is ignoring her requests to hear her case, and instead keeps adjourning the hearings. On nine occasions since April, 2011, Edward's wife was taken from her cell in southern Georgia at midnight for a long drive shackled, and at 4 a.m. stuck in a cage in the basement of the Atlanta court where she was held until after Cassidy would return from his lunch at 1 pm, at which point Cassidy would utter various inane non-legal reasons for deferring her case, including that her husband was not allowed in the building and that she needed to have an attorney. (According to Edward, "My wife replied, 'I brought three lawyers to this court already and you scared them all off.'")

Then his wife, shackled at her hands and feet, would be taken back down to the basement and held for several hours before the return trip to Ocilla, each trip a 24 hour ordeal.


WHY IS CASSIDY DOING THIS?
Edward's complaints to the ICE Field Office about his wife's health -- he called at least once daily until she was given her medication -- perhaps pissed off the ICE thugs. For whatever reason, Cassidy, himself a former INS prosecutor, is scaring off Edward's attorneys with different versions of a false and defamatory statement that Edward assaulted an ICE agent and also issued a death threat against an ICE agent, and thus is not allowed in the building.

When Edward first heard this, he was incredulous. "If i did do it, I would have been jail," he said, explaining that in May, 2011 the guards simply told him to leave and gave him no reason whatsoever.

WHY WAS CASSSIDY ABLE TO SCARE OFF THE ATTORNEYS?
A former federal law enforcement investigator who now practices immigration law voiced a sentiment others have as well: immigration attorneys tend to be wimps. Many of the folks who have daily transactions with Cassidy prefer easy dealings with him over justice and the rule of law. Instead of telling Cassidy that Edward's physical presence in the court was irrelevant to his wife's prolonged detention and petition for relief, the attorneys withdrew from the case.

Edward told me, "This is not a real court. You are at the mercy of the whole government when you go there. He does not run the court. ICE runs the court."

Edward called me because he'd read my blog, wanted his story told, and knew I would understand what he was telling me.

SPEAKING OF APRIL 19, 2010...
So, for folks who have any memory of my own experience of Cassidy ordering me removed from the same Atlanta building from which Edward was removed, this seems a bit paradoxical. On the one hand ICE is determining the agenda for the EOIR removal hearings described above. But on the other hand, Cassidy was indeed ordering the private Paragon security guards contracted to run the building security for the Federal Protective Services to kick me out, even though he has zero legal authority for this. And then his cronies in Falls Church covered it all up, also in violation of the regulations for investigating misconduct. What is going on?

Over the past 20 months since this happened, I have been receiving dribs and drabs of responses to my FOIA requests for the documents associated with that event, including contemporaneous recordings, reports, e-mail, and court dockets. The hypothesis I put together last week based on these is that Cassidy wanted me out because he didn't want me to see someone who was scheduled that day and that the EOIR wanted to cover this up because that's what they do.

That is, in reviewing April 19, 2010 docket, I noticed a hearing scheduled for someone who was seeking asylum and was having hearings deferred for bizarre and incoherent reasons. It occurred to me that maybe Cassidy didn't want me to see watch their interaction, and that's why he approached me around 3 pm, out of line of the camera that would feed his statements to Stewart, and told me I had to leave.

So when Edward told me about his wife's current plight, a scenario that fits exactly what I suspected from the docket and other communications of April 19, he provided information consistent with my belief that the reason Cassidy did not want me there was that he wanted to make sure no one knew about how he was fixing things for his pals at ICE. Meanwhile, the communications show that his buddies in EOIR headquarters were covering up for Cassidy.

Here's what I knew first-hand (this is from a contemporaneous post on April 20, 2010)--for the entire post, please go here:

The immediate trigger for Mr. Cassidy's ordering private guards to have me removed appears to be an exchange we had shortly after 3 pm. I was the sole observer as he left the bench and, out of the camera's line of vision, walked toward me and asked me to leave. I asked him why. He said he had the authority to close hearings. I said that immigration hearings were generally open to the public subject to certain exceptions. I asked him if the respondent had requested a closed hearing. He said "No, the respondent is pro se," meaning without an attorney.

Mr. Cassidy also said he could order me removed. I asked if he would give me a reason for why he was closing the hearing. He thought for a few seconds and then said, "No," and told me he was getting the regulation on closing hearings and that I should wait. I told him I was familiar with the regulation. He nonetheless left the court through the rear exit.

Concerned about his implied threat earlier and also not interested in continuing this exchange I told the interpreter and administrator that I was going to the front office and that if the respondent happened to have understood what was happening and wanted me back, I would be there. The entire episode occurred in about 90 seconds.
Next I had a conversation with a court administrator in the front office about what happened and expressed my concerns about Cassidy's disregard for the regulation on public access to immigration courts; then I sat down and wrote up my notes about what was going on; and then a few guards approached and rattled their handcuffs and pushed me out.

And then a couple of months later there was the fake investigation by Gary Smith in the EOIR headquarters.

Here's what the government documents produced in response to my FOIA requests show:

1) A copy of Cassidy's hearings scheduled that day show one for someone pro se who was claiming asylum, did not have a criminal record, and had been in detention since June 6, 2009, and still was in detention after November 12, 2010 and perhaps is still there, with 20 adjournments for reasons including Quarantine, Unplanned IJ Absence, Data Entry Error, and Televideo Failure. He was being held at Stewart. He might not be so happy about this arrangement and Cassidy might not want me to hear about it.

2) At 3:13 pm Susan Eastwood at the EOIR headquarters in Falls Church sent an email message to Lauren Alder Reid and copied it to Elaine Komis, Kathryn Mattingly, and Crystal Riley with the subject heading "Jackie Stevens at the Atlanta Immigration Court." (Most of these people are in Public Affairs.)
Judge Cassidy just called to advise that he had to ask Jackie to leave the courtroom while he conferred with counsel. She apparently put up a fuss, asking if either counsel for ICE or counsel for the respondent wanted her there (neither responded), and eventually left.
When I was in Cassidy's court I asked him if the respondent had asked to close the hearing and he told me the respondent was "pro se," meaning without an attorney, and he said this was not an asylum hearing. (After Cassidy left the court I told the clerk I would be in the front office in case the respondent wanted me to observe the hearing.)

The EOIR's email shows that Cassidy was asking me to leave so that he could speak privately with the government attorney, a clear violation of the regulation prohibiting ex parte communications, a violation the Board of Immigration Appeals noted Cassidy has committed previously. Perhaps this is why Cassidy never gave me this explanation, but just told me I had to go.

On April 19, 2010 Lauren Alder Reid answered my telephone call shortly before 5 pm and did not reveal that she had received the email quoted above. She told me that immigration judges, because they are part of the DOJ, have no authority over DHS employees. It is this division of authority that the DOJ uses to skirt the fact that by holding hearings in detention centers they violate the regulation requiring them to be public.

On April 23, 2010 Reid sent me an email stating, "I have been unable to verify your account." Also in that time frame she exchanged emails with her colleagues exploring the "possible banning" of me "from immigration courts."

4) According to a transcript from the DHS Megacenter in Battle Creek, Michigan from April 19, 2010, a guard called at 3:25 pm to report an "incident." The transcript of the phone call says, "the judge and one of the ladies that's over at the court hearing advised us to escort her out of the building." Later the operator says, "Who asked you to escort her off? The judge?" The guard says, "The judge, yes m'am."

The guard also states he doesn't know much "'cause we wasn't told everything that happened, that transpired in there until afterwards. We were only told to just escort her off the property. So, when we came back in, they gave us everything then, of what went on."

This transcript is the smoking gun, so to speak, that proves not only that Cassidy did in fact order me removed, but also that everyone knew this and that instead of investigating my misconduct complaint, Gary Smith patched together a cover-up.

5) 4/20/2010 from Marion Crosby, Supervisory Legal Assistant in Atlanta for the EOIR to her boss, Cynthia Long, the court administrator and copied to someone whose name is redacted. The email describes our exchange after I left Cassidy's court and went to the EOIR waiting room to find out why I'd been thrown out:
As [Name Redacted] and I were headed toward the reception window, Judge Cassidy had come out of court to inform us that the case is an Asylum case. I go to the reception window and inform Ms. Stevens that the case is an an asylum case and that is why the judge had asked her to step out.
Note that this reference to an asylum case as the reason for my exclusion is inconsistent with what Cassidy told the EOIR and what he told me.

Crucially, the email also states,
Based on her persistence I went to security and informed them that the Judge did not want her to be in courtroom 5. Officer [Redacted] was proceeding to the Immigration Court waiting room, and I informed him that I was not requesting for her to leave the building, but she is currently not allowed in courtroom #5" (emphasis added).
Crosby appears to be the court staff referenced by the guard, and, consistent with his own report to Battle Creek, only Cassidy, not Crosby, requested my removal from the building.

At that point, as I explained in my post of April 20, 2010, the goons did not find my gait to their satisfaction and pushed me out. Not surprisingly, despite the numerous cameras in the building and the filing of an incident report, Federal Protective Services did not save the video.

THE COVER-UP...
I'll be posting on this separately, but here's an overview.

From the moment I first tried to gain access to immigration courts in detention centers and was rebuffed, the EOIR position has been that DOJ controls DOJ buildings and DHS controls everything else. This was the rationale for the DOJ allowing for closed hearings: the immigration courts are open, and too bad for the media if they can't make it past the DHS guards.

Since the DOJ employees are not authorized to order around DHS employees, then this means that Cassidy had no legal authority to have me removed from the federal building in Atlanta. And that means that when he told guards to remove me he was conspiring with them to commit assault and battery. In other words, Cassidy's legal authority to have the Paragon guards kick me out is the same as if I hired them to kick him out.

It would be one thing if DHS employees or contractors could claim they saw me do something illegal and use that as the basis for removing me. But this didn't happen, as the transcript proves. Therefore, the EOIR and DHS had to conspire to cover-up what did happen or they all would be in trouble.

Why Post This Now?
Edward's wife is in trouble now because of Cassidy's delays in ruling on her case and ICE's mistreatment of her, including not releasing to her the results of a CAT scan. But it is impossible to prove Cassidy's and ICE's concoctions for her case in real-time. The FOIA responses I have from my encounters in 2010 prove a conspiracy to break the law and cover this up that reaches to the top levels of the EOIR, demonstrating that the agency is rife with cronyism and designed to exploit the hardships of U.S. citizens and their loved ones, and also obsessed with hiding all this from the media.

I'll be documenting this and much more in the next few weeks. If you want an email notice of new content, please click here.

Wednesday, July 27, 2011

How ICE Deported Another US Citizen, Andres Robles Still In Mexico



Andres Robles, 22, has a letter from US Citizenship and Immigration Services sent on June 15, 2011 stating he "derive[d] citizenship on June 13, 2002, when your father became a naturalized citizen of the United States." But the letter, under the Department of Homeland Security official insignia, is no protection against the armed gangs that roam San Isidro in Apozol, Zacatecas, where he's been staying with his grandmother since he was wrongfully deported when he was 19:
There's a lot of shooting, mafias. They do decapitations. The police don't really do nothing about it. They had a fair but no one went because of the mafia picking up people.
A post last week describes the absurd failures of the U.S. government to rectify it's admitted errors, including how the consular officers in Matamoros are failing to protect a U.S. citizen from the dangers described above.

The post here describes how this happened.

Andres, who speaks with a slight Louisiana drawl and understood little Spanish before his deportation, was ordered removed from his country on December 16, 2008 by an adjudicator he believes is John Ducks from the Oakdale Immigration Court because of the following miscarriages of justice and the law.

1) Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents in the jail where he was first interviewed and then at what sounds like the regional Criminal Alien Program subfield office ignored his statements asserting U.S. citizenship because they didn't believe him, in the first place, and because, in the second, investigating them would be too much of a bureaucratic hassle.

In jail,
They [ICE] asked me if I had my papers and stuff, and at that time I didn't have an ID. I was 17. I didn't have any type of ID. I told him I had a father who is a US citizen and he said, 'Really, do you?' I told him, yeah. But he had a face like, yeah, right, like he didn't believe me.
This was at the Terribone Juvenile Detention Center, where ICE is busy deporting teenage US citizens.

At the small office where Andres was taken in 2008 after he finished his jail sentence, he again told the agent interviewing him that his father was a US citizen and he believed he also could be a US citizen:
I told them right there, too, about my father, and they said they would look into it. I remember they were going to show it to the main person there, but he didn't agree. They said just take him up to the jail. The person talking was a young person. He was alright, telling me what was going on. That's how I know the main officer there didn't agree, said it was too much paperwork.
The guy running the office knew that ICE was not allowed to detain US citizens, but simply ignored the plea to check the USCIS database. A few minutes of searching would have verified not only the US citizenship of Mr. Robles' father, but also the names and ages of his children, an easy means of confirming that the person in their custody was indeed the same person who had derived US citizenship when his father naturalized in 2002 and therefore should not be in deportation proceedings.

2) During the hearing the adjudicator ignored Andres and his attorney failed to appear telephonically twice. The first time, no one was available when the adjudicator called the law offices and the second time, a secretary appears to have participated by telephone instead of the attorney.

Mr. Robles' father hired an attorney who then failed to appear in the telephonic hearing, and instead designated his secretary to take the call from the immigration judge and simply agree to the deportation.
I told him [John Duck, Andres believes] that my father was a U.S. citizen. He didn't say much. I think he said it was too late to say that. They were just talking among themselves with the DA [the IJ, the immigration attorney's secretary, and the ICE trial attorney]. They asked me if I wanted to fight the case and everything, and I said not really, because I didn't want to stay another year in jail. So I got deported.
According to Maria Robles, Andres' older sister, the current attorney, Lawrence Fabacher, and her father have been faxing and calling the office of this attorney to request the file. "He's in hiding. He just ignores everyone. He's an attorney. He should have taken care of this. He basically just stole our money." Maria also told me that the secretary who appeared on behalf of the attorney quit because she didn't approve of how he ran his business.

(I left messages today at the two offices for Andres' first attorney, someone who runs one of those places that promises to sue for your back injury and help you immigrate. I will publish his name after he has a chance to respond to their allegations.)

[UPDATE August 30: The attorney Andres Robles' family hired and whose actions are described above is Rigeur Silva; he also ignored my several phone messages left with his receptionists in two offices, voice mail messages, and email messages seeking comment on these claims.]

3) ICE and the State Department's Consular Services are doing nothing to rectify their error.

When Mark Lyttle was deported, the consular office in Guatemala City contacted his family and within six hours had issued him a U.S. passport. Consular Affairs spokesperson Rebecca Dodds was not familiar with the deportation of US citizens and was very surprised when I told her about the expeditious treatment of Mark Lyttle, suggesting that official protocols would have required he wait much longer, though providing no information on these. "If someone comes into the consulate and speaks with an American accent and doesn't have the papers, then we would do what it takes to assist them." She refused to comment on why this did not occur in the Matamoros consular office because I did not have a privacy waiver and she is "never allowed to speak about a U.S. citizen," a status the State Department will assert only for the purpose of denying information about inept consular officers, as opposed to recognizing as a slam dunk acknowledgement that Andres should be allowed to return.

(Since USCIS has issued a letter to Andres signed by Jonathan Crawford verifying his US citizenship, there is no reason it should take more than a few minutes or hours at the most to verify the letter's authenticity by phone or email. If consular officer Maria Alvarado, who handled Mark Lyttle's passport in the Guatemala City, were in Matamoros, Andres Robles would be with his parents in Louisiana today.)

As usual, ICE has no response to queries about the agency's ongoing civil rights violations committed against U.S. citizens who appear to be of Mexican descent, other than spokesperson Ernestine Fobbs assuring me she is pursuing one.

Ms. Fobbs said she also was the person who was not responding to my earlier inquiries about the deportation, detention, and release of Marine and U.S. citizen George Ibarra over two months ago, even though the ICE Arizona spokesperson and my point of contact for that story was Vincent Picard. Ms. Fobbs claims to be still working on that but will provide no timeline for a response.

Thursday, July 21, 2011

USCIS Says ICE Deported US Citizen, Andres Robles Still Stuck in Mexico




Andres Robles is celebrating his 22d birthday today in Mexico and not with his parents in Thibodaux, Louisiana because the U.S. government once again deported a U.S. citizen.

Instead of following the law that says U.S. citizens cannot be detained, much less deported, the government is channeling Kafka.

The letter Mr. Robles received over a month ago care of his attorney Lawrence Fabacher speaks for itself:
Dear Mr. Robles,

Your N-600 Application for a Certificate of Citizenship was approved on June 15, 20011 [sic]. You derive [sic] citizenship on June 13, 2002, when your father became a naturalized citizen of the United States. However, since you were deported from the United States, we are unable to complete the N-600 application process and provide you with a certificate of citizenship.

Upon your return to the United States, please make an appointment at the USCIS office closest to your current location. At that time, the local office will be able to assist you in obtaining your certificate of citizenship....

We have papers that will authorize your presence inside the Castle, Mr. Robles. But since we mistakenly threw you out of the Castle, you may not obtain them. Once you enter the Castle, we will be happy to provide you papers that will authorize your entry.

Mr. Robles is not without assistance. His attorney, Lawrence Fabacher, reached out to the Oakdale, Louisana ICE offices. ICE told Mr. Fabacher that Mr. Robles would have to resolve this matter at the U.S. consulate in Mexico. Andres' father flew down to Mexico and met his son at the U.S. consular office in Matamoros, a border city that is a 12 hour bus ride from Andres' current home with his grandmother in a small village 40 mountainous miles north of Puerto Vallarta.

When we spoke by phone yesterday, Mr. Robles said that the consular officer told them they did not issue "that kind of passport" and refused to assist him.

Andres' sister Maria, 26, also a U.S. citizen, told me that when her parents shared with her the results of their trip to the consular office over two weeks ago they were all devastated, "It's like the world's coming down on our shoulders. They were crying. He's growing up without us. I try to help them but I feel so useless."

Maria had in fact managed to track down someone in the U.S. Consular Office in Nuevo Laredo who followed up on her concerns and induced someone in the State Department in Washington, D.C. to call Andres. Andres told me, "He asked me all the questions you are asking: where I first crossed, the first time I crossed over, how old I was and all of that, where I went to school. They told me he would call me back and get me my passport, that I could pick it up at a border crossing."

But no one ever called back and the number he had for the individual with whom he spoke two weeks ago was a nonworking number with an area code for Trinidad and Tobago, perhaps the result of a transcription error.

Happy birthday, Andres. Hang in there. Wouldn't it be a nice present if the guy from the State Department called back today! You told me that you thought you'd been there since New Year's Eve, 2009, but I just checked and the immigration judge you think deported you, John Duck at Oakdale, ordered your removal on December 16, 2008, a week after the adjudicator William Cassidy ordered Mark Lyttle's deportation unlawful deportation.

I will post more on how Andres came to be deported early next week.

And I will also report any response to this from ICE or the State Department, though I am not holding my breath. ICE ignored U.S. citizen and ex-Marine Geoge Ibarra's privacy waiver instructing the government to share information with me about his unlawful detention and deportations, even though ICE spokesperson Vincent Picard assured me that this would be forthcoming. (ICE ignored Mr. Ibarra's probative evidence of U.S. citizenship, i.e., an immigration judge finding he was a U.S. citizen!, and continued to hold him for several months while it filed its appeal, releasing him without explanation only after I wrote about this and major news outlets were arranging interviews with Mr. Ibarra at the Eloy Detention Center.)

This most recent episode of ICE silence on its malfeasance confirms that ICE under the Obama administration is misusing funding Congress appropriated for providing public information and is instead devoting these resources to its propaganda machine and hiding from the American people the practices it is using to unlawfully detain and deport U.S. citizens and other residents.

A research article on this topic, "US Government Unlawfully Detaining and Deporting US Citizens" will be appearing shortly in the University of Virginia Journal of Social Policy and the Law, vol 18 (3).

Wednesday, December 8, 2010

EOIR Attorney Conceals Memorandum With Evidence of Unlawful Restrictions on Media Access





NOTE THE DOCUMENT BELOW IS PRODUCED AFTER EOIR RECEIVES FOIA REQUEST. EARLIER RESPONSIVE DOCUMENT(S ) CONCEALED.


Among the many causes of the government unlawfully deporting U.S. residents, including U.S. citizens, is the effective secrecy in which many immigration hearings are conducted. (For more on this, please see "Lawless Courts," The Nation, October 20, 2010.)

A misconduct complaint I submitted on Monday, December 6 to the Department of Justice (DOJ) Office of the Inspector General (OIG) describes an unlawful policy reported to me by immigration court staff across the country. According to a policy of the Executive Office of Immigration Review (EOIR) Office of Legislative and Public Affairs (OLPA), court staff nationwide are asked to detain media representatives attempting to enter open hearings until receiving permission for their entrance from EOIR's public affairs office.

My misconduct complaint alleges violations of 8 CFR 1003.27 - Public access to hearings;18 USC § 2071 - (Concealment, removal, or mutilation generally); and serious administrative misconduct (wanton disregard for agency procedures for implementing 5 USC § 552, Freedom of Information and Privacy Act).

The OLPA policy is unlawful and so was EOIR OLPA Counsel Lauren Alder Reid's concealing from the EOIR's FOIA staff at least one memorandum providing evidence of it. (Late Monday I sent Ms. Reid and her colleagues a copy of the misconduct complaint, indicated I would be posting it on my blog, and asked if they wanted to comment on it. I have not received a reply.)

Pieces of the media monitoring policy are laid out in a memorandum that was issued under the name of Lauren Alder Reid, Counsel for OLPA, and, according to notes from my transcription while inspecting the document, "updated August 14, 2009." I had this document in mind and described it when I submitted the August, 2010 FOIA request.

This memorandum describes a policy whose implementation requires EOIR court staff detaining court visitors in order to ascertain if they are with the media. Especially troubling is that, according to FOIA staff, Ms. Reid concealed its existence from that office, which in turn failed to produce it in response to a request I filed in August.

(The EOIR FOIA office forwarded to Ms. Reid a FOIA request I submitted describing the document in question. In fact, Ms. Reid herself told me to request the agency policy through the FOIA process. Rather than produce the incriminating document, Ms. Reid, after a considerable delay, submitted to her colleagues a document that was produced AFTER the EOIR received my FOIA request and withheld from her colleagues the memorandum in question, one that she herself appears to have written and circulated.)

As I noted earlier, the EOIR's own misconduct complaint process is a sham, and indeed those administering it are themselves violating the rules that require government employees to direct evidence of serious misconduct to the DOJ OIG or Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR). Thus, EOIR stakeholders are best served by filing their complaints directly with these agencies.

28 USC 0.29c(a) states: Reporting to the OIG. Evidence and non-frivolous allegations of criminal wrongdoing or serious administrative misconduct by Department employees shall be reported to the OIG, or to a supervisor or a Department component's internal affairs office for referral to the OIG, except as provided in paragraph (b) of this section.)

"b"is similar, but requires reporting adjudicative misconduct, i.e., immigration judge misconduct, to the OPR, something MaryBeth Keller and other supervisors, including Gary Smith, fail to do. (Mr. Smith is the guy who has been covering-up for William Cassidy in Atlanta, including ignoring requests from the FOIA staff, itself serious administrative misconduct.)

For other experts recommending sending complaints about immigration judges to the OPR and not the EOIR, please read "The Immigration Judge War," a chapter from a textbook on the immigration courts.

Jonathan D. Montag and Socheat Chea write:
Although the Office of the Chief of the Immigration Judge (OCIJ) also accepts complaints of judicial misconduct,44 it appears the more effective practice would be to submit allegations of misconduct to the OPR. The EOIR stated at an AILA liaison meeting that the OCIJ will make its own preliminary assessment, and if it determines that the charges have substance, only then will it refer the complaint to the OPR. An immigration practitioner’s best approach is to file the charges with OPR, since it is separate from the EOIR branch.
Shockingly, as I learned from a FOIA response from the OPR, even when the EOIR finds that charges are non-frivolous, it still fails to comply with the law and withholds this evidence from the OPR, allowing EOIR supervisors to arbitrarily protect and punish its employees without the oversight Congress mandates.

The EOIR also withholds evidence of serious administrative misconduct from the DOJ OIG, something I learned from the OIG desk attorney last Wednesday when she insisted that the EOIR was not part of the DOJ but part of the DHS, an inference that makes sense de facto but was surprising to hear from a DOJ attorney.

(As this had been misinformation conveyed by a high-ranking DHS official to me with similar confidence on a previous occasion I had a certain ethnographic curiosity about this confusion. I told the DOJ OIG desk attorney the EOIR really was part of the DOJ and said I wanted to understand why she thought that the EOIR was part of the DHS. "Because it is," she snapped, and then said, "Have a nice day" and hung up the phone.)

In the event, the misconduct complaint against Ms. Reid
is here, perhaps to be investigated by the attorney who thinks the EOIR is part of the DHS, .

Exhibit A ("Lawless Courts") is here.
Exhibits B and C (email concerning events at Falls Church immigration courts, June 23 and 24)
Exhibit D (August 10, 2010 FOIA request text file, omitting personal contact information)
Exhibit E (EOIR FOIA response with document produced September 9, 2010)

I realize that the details of all this are too arcane for most people but am posting this because it may be useful for a few, especially researchers, journalists and civil rights activists encountering similar unlawful obstructions and obfuscations.

Sunday, November 21, 2010

Update on Law-breaking and Misconduct at the Atlanta Immigration Courts


The Executive Office of Immigration Review (EOIR) has been on notice for quite some time that its adjudicators have been obstructing access to the immigration courts in Atlanta and also destroying evidence of this.

This post
- publishes a recent misconduct complaint I submitted to the Department of Justice (DOJ) Office of the Inspector General (OIG) and the Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR), and the context for this;

- links to the Twitter account for Professor Vincent Lloyd, who has been attending hearings at the Atlanta Immigration Courts in the last few weeks; and

- reports information from respondents appearing in William Cassidy's court quoting him indicating his impending retirement, even though he is under the normal retirement age for federal employees.

MISCONDUCT COMPLAINT
Instead of forwarding the information about serious employee misconduct to the DOJ or the DOJ OPR as required by law (28 USC 0.29c(a) and (b)), longtime EOIR supervisor MaryBeth Keller, responsible in recent years for supervising misconduct investigations of immigration judges, has swept these under the rug, prioritizing agency face-saving over protecting the rights of indigent respondents.

The statute states:
Evidence and non-frivolous allegations of criminal wrongdoing or serious administrative misconduct by Department employees shall be reported to the OIG, or to a supervisor or a Department component’s internal affairs office for referral to
the OIG, except as provided in paragraph(b) of this section.
(b) Reporting to the Department’s Office of Professional Responsibility (DOJ-OPR).
Employees shall report to DOJ-OPR evidence and non-frivolous allegations of serious misconduct by Department attorneys that relate to the exercise of their authority to investigate, litigate, or provide legal advice.
According to EOIR data posted online, dozens of complaints were received that would appear to meet the level of providing evidence of serious misconduct by up to 88 immigration judges last year, but, according to reports I received from the OPR, no one from the EOIR passed these on to the OPR.

(Ms. Keller and other middle management bureaucrats supervising immigration courts have the job title "Assistant Chief Immigration Judge," another symptom of the EOIR's pomposity and opacity -- most of these individuals do not hold any hearings or issue opinions. Perhaps the more accurate title would be Assistant TO THE Chief Immigration Judge but such directness would be an agency anomaly.)

In a delightfully revealing comment during our June, 2010 conversation about the agency's cover-up of Atlanta adjudicator William Cassidy's misconduct, Ms. Keller said, in a sing-song voice a parent might use when catching a child in hide-and-seek, "I can hear you typing," interrupting her speech about the EOIR's new commitment to transparency. (I kid you not.)

In the event, in light of her and Acting Director Thomas Snow's prioritization of public relations over enforcing the rule of law, over the next few weeks I will be passing on information to the OIG and OPR myself, and sending these misconduct complaints to the respective state bar associations as well as posting them here.

ORIGINAL DOCUMENTS HERE:
Complaint 11/21/10
Exhibit A (cover letter on destroyed docket information)
Exhibit B (docket with missing cases)

The first misconduct complaint documents long-standing access problems at the Atlanta Immigration Courts, including my colleague Vincent Lloyd's recent encounter with adjudicator Wayne Houser. Mr. Houser told Dr. Lloyd that he could not attend an asylum hearing, but did not indicate the legal reason for this.

(As the complaint points out, EOIR rules indicate asylum hearings are open to the public unless the respondent requests a closed hearing; according to Professor Lloyd, Mr. Houser did not indicate that the respondent had requested a closed hearing.)

Professor Lloyd has been attending hearings in Atlanta during the last few weeks and will be episodically reporting in real time the dockets for each day, so that anyone interested in observing hearings for detained respondents in particular might be on notice to attend. (These are generally in the morning and at this point are for people being bussed in from Etowah, Alabama and northern Georgia; hearings for respondents locked up in Stewart are largely being handled by the adjudicators in that facility.)

Mr. Houser has an exceptionally high rate of denying asylum claims (83%, according to TRAC), meaning respondents are more at risk from him failing to follow due process--more likely if the hearings are held in secret--than from a foreign agent impersonating Professor Lloyd for the purpose of harming the respondent or her family (preventing this being the goal of the asylum rule on requesting closed hearings is to prevent this).

DING-DONG? CASSIDY RETIRING?
In the last couple of months I have received two independent reports from people who reported to a third party via telephone and email (forwarded to me), respectively, that Mr. Cassidy announced to respondents in October that he will be retiring at the end of November.

On hearing the first report, I contacted the EOIR and also sent an email to Mr. Cassidy informing them of this report and indicating that I was intending to publish this information and was requesting their comment. I also pointed out that it appeared that the only justification for this retirement would be if the EOIR had fired him.

(Federal employees typically must be 55 before they retire; however there is an exception, among others, for employees who are under 55 and have worked for the federal government at least 20 years, as is the case for Mr. Cassidy, and have an "involuntarily separation," typically following poor performance reviews.)

I received an unsigned reply from the EOIR instructing me to file a FOIA request--comical in light of the agency's frequent failure to reply to these--and no reply from Mr. Cassidy.

Professor Lloyd informed me that in recent weeks Mr. Cassidy was not listed as holding hearings on a few occasions when Professor Lloyd had stopped by and that there was no docket posted for Mr. Cassidy in Atlanta on Friday, November 19, though other adjudicators were holding hearings.

POSTSCRIPT:
Why is the EOIR's Office of General Counsel persecuting immigration attorneys who prevail in the federal courts or otherwise embarrass the immigration judges? More on this to come.